Unauthorized Condo Renovations Can Cost You More Than You Think

Lance Luke

11/17/20265 min read

Just because you own a condominium unit does not mean you can renovate it any way you want.

Some owners believe that if they pay for the construction, they should be able to make whatever changes they want. Remove a wall, relocate plumbing, expand a kitchen, or modify electrical systems.

But condominium ownership is different from owning a single-family home. Changes inside one unit can affect the entire building, including shared plumbing systems, fire protection, structural components, and neighboring units.

A court case in New York demonstrates what can happen when condominium owners ignore approved construction plans and building requirements.

A Condominium Renovation That Ended Up in Court

In Board of Managers of The Alfred Condominium v. Miller, 2024 NY Slip Op 32520(U), a condominium owner in New York was involved in a dispute with the condominium board over unauthorized renovations.

The owner had obtained approval for certain improvements, but the construction went beyond what the board had authorized.

Among the alterations identified in the court proceedings were:

  • Relocation of a hot-water riser serving other condominium units.

  • Changes to the kitchen layout and plumbing systems.

  • Relocation of a stove and gas line.

  • Installation of wall materials that did not meet applicable fire protection requirements.

  • Installation of glass guardrails that were too low.

  • Door alterations that did not comply with accessibility requirements.

  • Unauthorized use or alteration of building common areas.

These were not simply cosmetic changes.

The modifications involved building systems and components that could affect occupant safety and the operation of the condominium building. The condominium association brought legal action to require the owner to correct the unauthorized work.

The Inspection Identified Serious Construction Problems

One of the important aspects of this case was the inspection evidence.

The condominium association presented findings from a licensed architect who inspected the alterations and documented deficiencies.

The findings addressed concerns involving fire protection, accessibility, soundproofing, energy conservation, and deviations from the approved construction plans. This is where the importance of proper building inspections becomes clear.

A finished renovation may look attractive, but that does not necessarily mean the work was performed correctly. You cannot determine whether plumbing, electrical, or fire protection systems comply with applicable requirements simply by looking at finished walls, floors, and cabinets.

Some of the most serious construction problems are hidden behind finished surfaces. That is why plans, specifications, permits, and inspections are important.

A renovation must be evaluated not only for appearance and workmanship but also for compliance with approved plans and applicable building codes.

The Court Ordered the Owner to Correct the Work

On July 12, 2024, the New York court ruled in favor of the condominium association.

The court determined that the owner had violated the condominium's bylaws and alteration agreement. The owner was ordered to correct, repair, and remedy the unauthorized alterations and illegal conditions within 90 days, at his own expense. The corrective work was also subject to the condominium association's specifications and final approval.

In addition, the court determined that the association was entitled to recover qualifying legal and professional expenses under the alteration agreement. The amount was left for a separate determination. Think about the financial consequences.

An owner pays for renovations, then faces additional expenses to correct or remove work that was not authorized or properly performed. Add legal expenses, professional inspections, and possible construction delays, and the costs can become substantial. That is an expensive way to learn the importance of following construction requirements.

Why Unauthorized Renovations Are a Building Safety Concern

Condominium buildings contain systems that serve multiple units.

An alteration in one unit may affect areas or equipment that other owners depend on.

  • Plumbing systems
    Relocating pipes, drains, or water supply lines without proper planning can create leaks, drainage problems, and water damage. A plumbing problem in an upper-floor condominium unit can affect several units below.

  • Electrical systems
    Improper electrical modifications can create shock hazards, overloaded circuits, and fire risks.

  • Fire protection
    Removing or modifying walls, doors, and other building components can compromise fire-rated assemblies and fire separation requirements.

  • Structural components
    Removing or altering structural walls and other load-bearing elements without proper evaluation can affect the building's structural integrity.

  • Accessibility and safety
    Improper guardrails, door configurations, and other alterations can create hazards for building occupants. These are reasons why condominium associations review construction proposals before renovations begin. The purpose is not simply to control what owners do inside their units. It is to help protect the building and the people who occupy it.

What Condominium Boards Should Do

Condominium boards and property managers need to pay attention to construction activities within their buildings.

When an owner proposes a renovation, the association should determine whether the work affects common elements, shared utilities, or building safety systems. Depending on the scope of construction, professional review may be necessary.

The board should verify that the required plans, approvals, and permits are in place before construction begins. When appropriate, inspections should also be performed during construction, especially before concealed work is covered.

If unauthorized alterations are discovered, the association should document the condition and obtain appropriate professional advice. The longer an unauthorized modification remains unaddressed, the more difficult and expensive it may become to correct.

Condominium boards should also work with their association attorney when determining enforcement options under their governing documents and applicable laws.

What Hawaiʻi Condominium Owners Should Know

The New York case provides a useful lesson for condominium communities in Hawaiʻi. Hawaiʻi has its own condominium laws, including Hawaii Revised Statutes Chapter 514B.

Under HRS § 514B-140, additions and alterations to condominium units and common elements are subject to requirements that depend on the nature of the work, the condominium's governing documents, and other applicable conditions.

Certain material alterations require more extensive approvals, while other alterations may require board approval and any additional consent specified in the governing documents.

Owners should not assume that every interior improvement is automatically permitted.

Before beginning a condominium renovation:

  1. Review the association's governing documents and renovation requirements.

  2. Determine which written approvals are necessary.

  3. Verify whether building permits are required.

  4. Use qualified and properly licensed professionals when required.

  5. Make sure construction follows the approved plans.

  6. Arrange required inspections before work is concealed.

  7. Keep records of permits, approvals, and inspection results.

If you are unsure about the requirements, consult your condominium association, the appropriate building department, and qualified professionals before starting construction.

Do not wait until the renovation is completed to find out whether it was allowed.

My Final Thoughts

The lesson from this New York case is straightforward.

Obtaining approval for a renovation does not give an owner permission to make additional changes without authorization. Construction must follow the approved plans and applicable requirements.

As a building expert, I emphasize the importance of identifying construction problems before they become expensive repairs or safety hazards.

The same applies to condominium renovations. Proper planning, qualified contractors, construction inspections, and communication with the condominium association can help prevent problems.

A renovation is not successful simply because the construction is finished. It must also be properly designed, approved, constructed, and inspected.

Before you renovate, know the rules. Get the necessary approvals. And make sure the work is done correctly.

It is much less expensive to do the job right the first time than to pay to correct it later.

References

United States Court Decision

Board of Managers of The Alfred Condominium v. Miller, 2024 NY Slip Op 32520(U), Supreme Court of New York, New York County, July 12, 2024.

https://law.justia.com/cases/new-york/other-courts/2024/2024-ny-slip-op-32520-u.html

Hawaiʻi Condominium Law

Hawaii Revised Statutes § 514B-140, Additions to and Alterations of Condominium.

https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol12_Ch0501-0588/HRS0514B/HRS_0514B-0140.htm

Legal requirements vary by jurisdiction and condominium governing documents. Owners and associations should consult qualified legal counsel regarding specific compliance or enforcement questions.

Lance Luke

National Building Expert

Building Consultant & Construction Expert

Phone: (808) 422-2132

Email: lanceluke@hawaiibuildingexpert.com

Website: hawaiibuildingexpert.com

Reach out anytime, we’re here to help.

Email

Phone

(808) 422-2132

© 2026. All rights reserved.

Contact

newsletter